Open-Faced Tomato Feta Sandwiches

I’ve found that whenever you set out to make something, there are ingredients, and there are Ingredients.  Sometimes…actually almost all of the time…using the best ingredients for whatever you are cooking up can turn the ordinary into the kind of meal that you eat slowly and with your eyes closed because it is just that good.  Take this little tomato and cheese sandwich that I recently made for dinner, for example.

It all started with these gorgeous heirloom tomatoes that I picked up at our local farmer’s market.  They were definitely more expensive than their non-heirloom friends over on the next table, and they were definitely not as handsome.  They had home-grown nicks and scars all over them.

For me, that’s the sign of a truly delicious tomato.  That and the fact that a mesmerizing fresh tomato aroma was swirling all around them.

I also had a loaf of fresh-baked country bread.  Just begging to be made into toast and drizzled with a little of this bottle of fabulous extra virgin olive oil that I hide in the back of my pantry and only bring out for drizzling purposes.  It’s that good.

I also had a hunk of my favorite feta cheese.  It’s the perfect mix of tender and salty and I have to stop myself from just eating the entire chunk before I slice it up.  I don’t usually lose it over feta cheese, but this one is a show stopper.

So here’s how this sandwich went: toasted country bread, drizzled with tangy olive oil, layered with sweet thick slices of in-season heirloom tomato, topped with the best feta cheese I know.  A little more olive oil, some fresh thyme leaves from my garden, and there you go.

One last footnote on this recipe – I originally found the idea for it in last summer’s August issue of Bon Appetit, and one of the many fun things that Bon Appetit is the opportunity to “cook the cover” – in other words, to make your own version of what is on their cover.  Now, this was an invitation I couldn’t resist…and click here for the results from Bon Appetit!

In the meantime, try this simple tomato sandwich, aka one of the best suppers I’ve had this summer.  Fresh ingredients rock!!  And you’re worth it.  :)

Open-Faced Tomato Feta Sandwiches

Serves: 1 serving

  • 2 slices lightly toasted country bread
  • 1 local tomato, sliced thickly
  • Sliced feta cheese
  • Coarse salt and fresh ground pepper
  • Fresh thyme
  • Olive oil
  1. Drizzle the toasted bread with olive oil.
  2. Layer a couple of tomato slices on each piece of bread. Top with feta cheese.
  3. Sprinkle with salt, pepper and fresh thyme. Drizzle with a little more olive oil.
  4. Enjoy!

Inspired by the Open Faced Tomato Sandwich Challenge in Bon Appetit



Want a photo beside your name? Go to, sign up for a free account, and upload a photo. It's super easy!

  1. Mmm. I have been enjoying Greek salads for the past couple of weeks, made with barrel aged feta and heirloom tomatoes, bread on the side.

  2. Yep, that pretty much sums up my vision of heaven. I can’t WAIT until my tomatoes are ripe. Bread, cheese, tomatoes, and fresh basil will be a constant.

  3. Yum!!! This sandwich looks incredible!

  4. I had something very similar to this last week but with the addition of bacon. 😉
    It was soooo good I had it on two days! Unfortunately my German thyme drowned in its pot in this deluge-crazed summer we’ve had so I had to sub in fresh basil, which apparently doesn’t mind all that water. Excellent meals.

  5. Love the feta tomato combo :)

  6. I’ve had my eye on this since the issue came out last year but was waiting for the perfect summer tomatoes to make it with. With a dish this simple, you only want to use the best since the ingredients are really going to shine!

  7. Oh, that looks so good! I have tomatoes and some feta I marinated, and a nice sourdough baguette which will be crunchy and stand up to tomato juices and olive oil really well. I can already taste it (and feel the juices running down my chin). Excellent, excellent idea.

    Thanks, Kate!

  8. Katharine says:

    I don’t quite know how I stumbled across your website, but what I do know is that I have spent the last few hours browsing all of your recipe pages! I have to say, everything you post looks absolutely delicious (including all the recipes with bacon – something I can’t seem to find a good relationship with). I can’t wait to try this one out, as feta is one of my favorite ingredient!

    • Katharine, I’m so glad you found me! And yes, this sandwich is the perfect summer lunch – hope you love it. :)

Let's Talk!


Subscribe to FramedCooks

To subscribe in your favorite reader, copy this link: and paste it
into your reader's 'new feed' tool.

To receive new posts via email, enter your email here: